I’ve commented on the new “professionalization” the ARRL CE program has agreed to: http://k9zw.wordpress.com/2009/11/03/emcomm-professionalization-marches-on/

Very interesting that you no longer need to have an FCC Amateur Radio License to be Emcomm (though you do need permission if you don’t and actually you need the same permission if you are licensed… but they make a distinction…)

Interesting times, and possibly moreso as the rules change.

73

Steve
K9ZW

Of course there is value in organization but it seems that the government/ham radio/emcomm alliance of the 21st century is a fairly rigid structure with radio hams doing all the dirty work, and apparently risking their license in the process, while the governmental agencies call all the shots.

Doesn’t it seem at least a little odd that US radio hams, who are made up primarily of political conservatives, seem intent on forging even closer connections with a government that they swear doesn’t work?

If your local government was effective when it comes to emergency communications then they wouldn’t need our help.

When did we decide that the best way to lend a hand to our neighbors in time of crisis was to become a de facto agent of the government?

73, Jeff

Reflecting back on this issue, I went back to Part 97.1a and verified that one of the stated purposes of the Amateur Radio Service is:

Recognition and enhancement of the value of the amateur service to the public as a voluntary noncommercial communication service, particularly with respect to providing emergency communications.

This really isn’t up for debate and from a public policy point of view, it is an important reason why we have access to the frequency spectrum. The debate seems to center on how to implement this purpose.

Jeff’s point is provocative….just walk away until something big happens. I have a hard time seeing this as very effective. I’ve noticed various hams taking this approach on a personal level — no connection at all to ARES, RACES, Red Cross, Salvation Army, etc. but then they are surprised that their offer of help during an emergency gets ignored simply because they are a total unknown. It seems like there has to be a base level of training/practice/coordination during normal times to be prepared for The Big One.

The second thing I’ve reflected on is there is a legitimate need to protect the amateur bands from being co-opted by non-amateur interests. In the limit, you could have the local police department doing dispatch on ham frequencies. Clearly, the FCC has blocked that off and it does not seem to be a present danger. I see that the Petition for Rulemaking from N4FDL and crew as a minor tweak that does not open the door too far.

Steve, what do you mean by “the take over of Amateur Radio Frequencies on a planned basis by served agencies”. Do you have specific examples of what you mean?

73, Bob K0NR

There is a much misinformation out there, and it would be well advised for any Amateur to touch base with the ARRL, rather than depend on any indirect internet sources, or opinions from others.

73

Steve
K9ZW

One idea that seems to have some merit is the concept of “Freecom.”

I’ve written a bit about it at:

http://k9zw.wordpress.com/?s=freecom

and there is a slowly growing Yahoo Group discussing it.

73

Steve
K9ZW

Training and drills, while not required, keep both groups in tune with each other. It helps the agencies know how Amateur Radio works, but it also helps the Amateur Radio folks know where they fit in into the grand scheme of things.

I think that this is a sign that we’re pushing Emergency Communications far too much in the hobby and neglecting the other parts. This provides up a chance to step back and reevaluate things.

The rules are clear that there *are no rules* in the event of a real emergency. Hams or anyone else for that matter can step in and operate over the air in any manner necessary (on any frequency with any power, etc.) if there is a potential for endangerment of life or of property.

Where we seem to be getting into trouble is during the times when that special exemption doesn’t apply.

Like simulated emergency “games” and practice with local officials. Radio amateurs seem to be the only ones at risk here and perhaps now is time for us to simply walk away and wait to offer our services when faced with the “real thing”…?

73 de Jeff, KE9V